How a $4 Mocha Can Change the Way You Work

We didn't always have offices.

Back when Matt and I were building Sporcle from scratch, our "headquarters" rotated between every coffee shop in Seattle that offered decent WiFi and had baristas patient enough to tolerate us. This was 2008, something of a digital dark age compared to today. No Zoom calls, no Slack channels, poor collaboration tools. When we weren't physically side-by-side, we'd communicate through AOL Instant Messenger of all things. Yes, that AOL, I am still haunted by the "You've got mail!" alert and the dial-up modem sounds.

Our somewhat daily ritual became predictable: land at a coffee shop in the morning, order some form of caffeine and muffins, claim the good table by the outlet, stretch that $4 mocha for a few hours until the staff's hints became unmistakable glares, then pack up and repeat somewhere else for the afternoon shift.

Eventually, the economics caught up with us. Between the coffee costs, parking nightmares, and the ongoing game of "find the password, find a seat," we surrendered to convention and rented actual office space.

But I sometimes miss those coffee shop days. There was a distinct productivity to them. Something about the ambient buzz of strangers, the gentle pressure of occupying public space, the background soundtrack of espresso machines and conversations that unlocked a different gear in my brain.

In today's remote-first world, where many of us find ourselves in the solitude of home offices, that coffee shop productivity feels like a distant memory. The isolation that initially seemed liberating has gradually revealed its costs to our focus and output. Many of us struggle to maintain concentration while working from home day after day. A simple change of scenery—whether for work projects, studying, or collaboration—can make a huge difference in what we can get done.

Turns out, this phenomenon has a name as well as research to back it up. It's called "The Audience Effect." So this week, let's explore the Audience Effect, what triggers this productivity boost, why it works even when nobody's watching you, and how you can harness it to revitalize your work when motivation runs dry.

What Is the Audience Effect?

The Audience Effect is one of those simple but surprisingly powerful psychological quirks: we perform better when we think someone else is around (even if they're not actively watching or judging us).

Just the sense of another person nearby can sharpen our focus, boost motivation, and nudge us to try a little harder. Our brains are a bit wired to kick into a higher gear just because we know we are in a shared space.

Ever noticed how you sit up straighter when someone walks into the room? Or how you perhaps type with more purpose when a colleague passes by your desk? That's the Audience Effect in action. It's why students often study better in libraries than in empty dorm rooms. It's why writers have descended on cafés for centuries.

Coffee shops provide the perfect balance: enough "social pressure" to keep you accountable to yourself, but not so much that you feel scrutinized. You're surrounded by people engaged in their own tasks, creating a gentle accountability without the stress of actual observation.

The Audience Effect is a close cousin of the Hawthorne Effect, where people change their behavior because they know they're being observed in a formal setting. But while the Hawthorne Effect is about being evaluated, the Audience Effect runs deeper. It taps into our social wiring—our instinct to be seen positively by others, even casually.

Cause sometimes the solution to your productivity woes is simply changing where you sit.

Beyond the Coffee Shop: Where to Find Your Audience

Not everyone can camp out at a café all day (or afford the coffee tab that justifies the table real estate). The good news is that the Audience Effect can be recreated in all sorts of different places.

The key is finding your personal sweet spot on the social-presence spectrum. Too many people or too much interaction can be distracting, while total isolation might leave your brain under-stimulated. Pay attention to where you naturally focus best, it might change depending on the task at hand.

• Libraries are a great structured alternative. They combine the focused energy of others working with an explicit social contract of silence.

• Co-working spaces provide a middle ground between coffee shops and traditional offices, with the added benefit of reliable WiFi and permission to stay all day.

• Public parks can work for some people; the ambient sounds of life happening around you can create just enough background energy.

For remote workers feeling isolated, there are even virtual options. That’s right, virtual co-working sessions, where you connect with others via video but work independently. Other people use accountability partners, checking in at the beginning and end of work sessions. Or it might be that just working with a YouTube video of a "study with me" session provides enough of the effect. But honestly, the whole point is to get out into the world.

For example, I took my son and his friends skiing a few weeks ago…and by "took them skiing," I mean I drove them up to Crystal Mountain while I spent the entire day in the lodge with my laptop. I don't ski, but as it turns out, I don't need to. The combination of mountain views, the steady parade of rosy-cheeked ski bums, and easy access to coffee, food, and reliable wifi makes for the perfect productivity bubble. I blazed through work that would have taken me twice as long at home. Sometimes I wonder if there's some sort of productivity vortex in the mountains, or if it's just the Audience Effect working its magic. I somehow transform into this work machine just because I'm surrounded by strangers in ski gear.

Try this today: Take a task you've been procrastinating on and work on it for 30 minutes in a public space. Pick somewhere with just the right amount of background presence: a quiet corner of a coffee shop, a library reading room, or even a park bench with people strolling by (weather permitting). No need for a panopticon of watchers (a fun little word I just learned from the aforementioned son); just a few random strangers going about their day is all it takes to trigger that productivity boost.

Harnessing the Effect: Practical Strategies for Different Work Styles

Like most productivity hacks, the Audience Effect isn’t one-size-fits-all. How it works best depends on your personality and the kind of work you're doing.

For the more introverted, too much social energy can be a drain. I think this very concept exhausts my wife just by talking about it. But it might be worth trying different spots that give a sense of presence without requiring interaction. For example, university libraries, museum cafés, or the quiet corners of bookstores. Headphones can offer an extra layer of focus while still letting you benefit from being around others.

Extroverts run into a different challenge: avoiding the pull to turn work time into social time. Pick places where you're less likely to run into people you know, or set clear boundaries about when you’ll socialize. Some extroverts actually focus better with more background activity, so busier environments, like a coffee shop or co-working space, might actually help rather than distract.

The kind of task matters here as well. Creative work often thrives in places with a bit of background noise (around 70 decibels is ideal, which is roughly coffee shop level). But if you're doing something more analytical or detail-heavy, you might need a quieter environment that still has a subtle sense of shared presence to keep you alert.

If you want to try this, it’s a good idea to experiment. Work from different spots and track how it feels. Did that blog post practically write itself in the downtown café? Did your brain finally solve that spreadsheet issue at the university library? Patterns like these reveal your personal productivity profile.

In Conclusion

It’s tempting to think of productivity as a personal battle: willpower versus distraction, discipline versus inertia. But what if some of our best work doesn’t come from digging deeper within, but from reaching slightly outside?

The Audience Effect reminds us that we are social creatures, even in our most solitary pursuits. And I like to think of productivity not just as a matter of managing time, but of managing energy and environment. Sometimes the simplest shift, like changing where you work rather than how you work, can unlock progress.

So this week, break your routine. Step outside your usual workspace, even just once. Find a spot with that quiet buzz, your version of the 2008 Seattle coffee shop. Then do me a favor: reply to this email and tell me where you went and what you got done. I’m building a crowdsourced productivity map, and your favorite spot might just become someone else’s secret weapon.

Because maybe that missing focus isn’t hiding in your to-do list. It’s waiting at the table by the outlet, next to a decent cup of coffee and the soft hum of people doing their thing.

After all, sometimes the best way to work alone…is to be alone together.

As always, thanks for reading,
Derek
Oh and have something interesting you think I should write about? You can reply to this email (or any other Chief Rabbit email) to suggest it. 

RATE TODAY’S EDITION